Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43, a.k.a. The Vulture Stone (pic credit: Andrew Collins).
GÖBEKLI TEPE'S VULTURE STONE: A WARNING ACROSS TIME OR SIGNPOST TO THE LAND OF THE DEAD?
PUTTING INTO PERSPECTIVE THE CARVED IMAGERY ON GÖBEKLI TEPE'S PILLAR 43 IN ENCLOSURE D
By Andrew Collins
A new theory claims that Göbekli Tepe's Vulture Stone (Pillar 43) is a snapshot of the sky in 10,950 BC showing the date and time of a comet impact. It interprets the stone's prominent carving of a vulture as the constellation Sagittarius, something championed by Graham Hancock in Magicians of the Gods. It also interprets all its other carved reliefs of animals as constellations, and identifies the ball-like object above the wing of the pillar's central vulture as the sun. Since this article is written by two academics and published in a scholarly journal its sensationalist and somewhat far-fetched claims have been picked up on by the international media, and even The New Scientist" magazine.
Although as I point out in my 2014 book Göbekli Tepe: Genesis of the Gods the earliest enclosures at Göbekli Tepe were almost certainly built as a response to the so-called Younger Dryas comet impact event of 10,800 BC, were used perhaps by shamans to counter the baleful influence of comets, and contain imagery relating to comets, Pillar 43's imagery more likely relates to early Neolithic beliefs and practices concerning the soul's journey from the earthly plane to the realm of the dead, something now accepted by some of the leading archaeologists working at the site. This new comet impact theory ignores the fact that Professor Klaus Schmidt identified the ball-like object above the wing of the vulture as a disembodied human head, an abstract symbol of the human soul, and fails to take into consideration that the stars of Sagittarius were never seen in the ancient Near East as a vulture, the bird most commonly seen as a psychopomp or soul bird in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic world at sites like Göbekli Tepe, Nevali Çori and Çatal Höyük in Turkey, and Jerf el-Ahmar in northern Syria. All the indications are that Pillar 43 reflects the soul's death journey to the sky-world. However, because this new theory is proposed by two academics it has grabbed the headlines.
Just remember it IS simply a theory. Just because it is written by academics doesn't necessarily make it right. What is more, it is just one of several interpretations already applied to the extraordinary carved imagery of Göbekli Tepe's Vulture Stone. Now is the time to create theories about the carved imagery at Göbekli Tepe. Yet more important is to make predictions that might be confirmed with future discoveries at the site. The results of my own predictions regarding Göbekli Tepe's layout and carved out are published in new book The Cygnus Key: The Denisovan Legacy, Göbekli Tepe and the Birth of Egypt, out later this year. In the meantime, let me put into perspective what we know about the carved imagery of Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 ...
Tepe's Pillar 43, otherwise known as the Vulture Stone, is
arguably the key to understanding the cosmic geography of the site's builders
and their belief in the soul's journey to the spirit world. Yet what does the
stone's relief of a funny-shaped vulture actually represent? For several years
it has been realised that the Scorpion shown immediately below the vulture is
almost certainly the constellation of Scorpius. But what about the vulture? Graham
Hancock and others believe it represents the constellation of Sagittarius. Graham
Hancock in his book Magicians of the Gods (2015)
writes that the scorpion on Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43, standing
in the north-northwestern section of Enclosure D's ringwall, signifies the constellation
of Scorpius.(1) Having stated this, he goes on to demonstrate that the funny-looking
vulture located immediately above it (see fig. 1) is the neighboring constellation
of Sagittarius, a theory proposed originally by American researcher Paul Burley,(2)
and now repeated by the academics who have proposed that the stone is a snapshot
of the heavens around 10,950 BC, their proposed date for the Younger Dryas impact
event. In their opinion, the ball-like object above the wing of the stone's central
vulture relief marks the position of the sun at this time. Other constellations
in the vicinity are reflected in the birds and animals shown around the vulture.
Hancock on the other hand, again following Burley's lead, argues that the relief of the ball-like object is the sun in Sagittarius at the time of the winter solstice between the years 1960 and 2040.(3) In this knowledge Hancock asks whether the carved imagery seen on the Vulture Stone might not be a coded message conveyed across time by the Göbekli builders of 11,500 years ago, the age of Enclosure D where the stone can be found. Could it be a warning to humanity telling us that during this 80-year window the comet responsible for a terrifying impact event at the commencement of the Younger Dryas event ca. 10,800 BC might once again threaten the world? This is a daring, bold and somewhat disturbing proposition that once made, is unlikely to be forgotten. But is it right? Is it even appropriate to interpret the carved imagery of Göbekli Tepe's Vulture Stone in this way?
Figure 1. Pillar 43 in Göbekli Tepe's Enclosure D showing its position in the structure's perimeter wall.
That the Göbekli builders built these extraordinary stone installations on a mountaintop across a period of 1,500 years with the primary purpose of counteracting the baleful influence of comets is one of the principal themes of my book Göbekli Tepe: Genesis of the Gods (2014). Here I state that even at the end of the Younger Dryas event, ca. 9600 BC, the Upper Palaeolithic populations of the Northern Hemisphere remained in absolute fear following a global cataclysm caused by a comet impact that devastated large parts of the North American and Eurasian continents at the beginning of the Younger Dryas, ca. 10,800 BC.(4) Hancock ably continues this theme in Magicians of the Gods, bringing together the most recent scientific evidence showing that this terrible catastrophe did indeed take place. Also certainly Hancock will now revise his own ideas to incorporate the view that Pillar 43 does indeed show a snapshot of the sky at the time of the comet impact, which is calculated by the authors of the new paper to be around 10,950 BC. Indeed, it will support his opinion that the stone is a warning of the potential return of the comet between 1960 and 2040.
Hancock is almost certainly right in asserting that the scorpion seen on Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 is the earliest known pictorial representation of the Scorpius constellation, something I argue also in Göbekli Tepe: Genesis of the Gods (2014) after the work of Juan Antonio Belmonte.(5) Yet going on to identify the stone pillar's carved relief of a vulture with the constellation of Sagittarius is, however, thwart with problems.
From earliest times across the Near East the vulture has been identified with just three constellations: Cygnus, the celestial bird of Hellenic tradition; Lyra, the celestial lyre of Orpheus, known also as the Falling Vulture; and Aquila, the celestial eagle called also the Flying Vulture. All three constellations are found in the same area of sky, their brightest stars - Deneb, Vega and Altair respectively - being known collectively as the Summer Triangle (see fig. 2).
Fig. 2. Star chart showing Cygnus as a swan, Lyra as both a vulture and lyre, and Hercules upside down to the right. Aquila lies just beyond the illustration's bottom left-hand corner.
The Stymphalian birds
In Greek Hellenistic mythology these three constellations were equated with, among other things, the three Stymphalian birds that were sent against Hercules in his Sixth Labour.(6) It is an association confirmed in the knowledge that all three asterisms are located in the vicinity of the constellation of Hercules. In Mesopotamian star-lore three similar birds attack the god Marduk, and these too were personified in the night sky as the constellations of Cygnus, Lyra and Aquila.(7) In the knowledge that the Greeks identified Marduk with Hercules, it becomes clear that the myth of the Stymphalian birds originated in Mesopotamia, where all three constellations were identified as winged creatures as early as the third millennium BC.(8)
The Stymphalian birds, collectively known as the Stymphalides or Harpies, are said to have been winged monsters with "the faces of women, the bodies of vultures, and claws upon their hands."(9) The fact that they were thought to be monstrous vultures confirms their link with the constellations in question, which are all identified as vultures in Greek Hellenic star-lore - Vultur cadens ("the falling vulture") in the case of Cygnus and Lyra, and Vultur volans ("the flying vulture") in the case of Aquila.(10)
So if the vulture on Pillar 43 does represent one of the Stymphalian birds (and, interestingly, there are in fact six birds of various species and sizes carved on the stone), then most likely it is Cygnus. Not only did the twin central pillars in Enclosure D (and also those in Enclosures B, C, E & H) accurately target the setting of Deneb, Cygnus's brightest star, during the epoch of their construction, but we also know that its porthole stone, which stands just a few meters to the east of the Vulture Stone, was positioned so that this astronomical spectacle could be witnessed each night on the local skyline. In other words, the imagery on the Vulture Stone was in some way related to the astral purpose behind the axial orientation of the installation in which it stood. In addition to this the funny-looking vulture on Pillar 43 almost perfectly matches the outline of the main stars of Cygnus during the suspected timeframe of construction of Enclosure D (see fig. 3).
Figure 3. Left, Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 with Cygnus overlaid and, right, star map showing Scorpius overlaid with Pillar 43's scorpion and Cygnus overlaid with the stone vulture (pic credits: Rodney Hale).
Cygnus in Armenia
One additional piece of information linking Cygnus with the symbol of a vulture in ancient Anatolia comes from Armenia, which borders Anatolia to the northeast. In the past, the influence of Armenia and its ruling dynasty extended as far south as Edessa, modern-day Sanliurfa, juat eight miles (13 kilometres) away from Göbekli Tepe. Indeed, many Armenians still inhabited the Sanliurfa region until the horrific atrocities of the Armenian Genocide of 1917. It is thus significant that in Armenian star lore the constellation of Cygnus is known as Angegh, a word meaning "vulture."(11) Of direct relevance here is the fact that an Armenian village named Angeghakot (a name reflecting the word "vulture"), close to the megalithic complex of Karahunj is thought to reflect the importance of the Cygnus constellation.(12) Karahunj is made up of hundreds of standing stones that together create the likeness of the Cygnus constellation in its guise as the vulture,(13) while the circular aperture in one prominently placed stone is said to target the transit of the Cygnus star Deneb as it crosses the meridian.(14) Karahunj as a whole is attributed to the Bronze Age, ca. 2500 BC, although the alignment toward Deneb argues for a much earlier date of construction, perhaps in the region of ca. 5500-5000 BC.(15)
angegh in the Armenian language can also means "angel," Cygnus
is seen in Armenia as a heavenly angel, as well as the celestial home of the angels.(16)
Yet prior to the rise of Christianity Cygnus in Armenia was quite simply a vulture,
just as it was on the Euphrates during the formative years of the Mesopotamian
civilizations that emerged in Lower Iraq from around 3000 BCE onward.
Paranatellons of Sagittarius
Nowhere on the Euphrates is Sagittarius identified as a vulture. Having said this all three Stymphalian birds-Cygnus, Lyra and Aquila - are classified as paranatellons of Sagittarius. A paranatellon is a constelletion seen to rise at the same time as one of the twelve zodiacal constellations, which in the case of Cygnus, Lyra and Aquila during the time frame in question was Sagittarius. Thus all three celestial birds came under the rule of Sagittarius. It was for this reason that the Mesopotamian form of Sagittarius, Pabilsag, a composite creature usually depicted with a horse's body, the tail of a scorpion, the wings of a bird and the head and torso of a male human figure holding a bow and arrow, is occasionally shown with birdlike feet.(17)
If the vulture on Pillar 43 does indeed represent one of these three celestial birds (and, interestingly, there are in all six birds of various species and sizes found among its carved relief), then it is likely to be Cygnus, not Sagittarius. This seemed confirmed in the knowledge that the twin central pillars in Enclosure D (and also those in Enclosures B, C & E) targeted the setting of Deneb, Cygnus's brightest star, during the epoch of its construction, ca. 9600-9500 BC, something confirmed by Italian archaeoastronomers Alessandro De Lorenzis and Vincenzo Orofino(18). Aside from this is the additional fact that the shape of the funny-winged vulture on Pillar 43 almost perfectly reflects the outline of the main stars of Cygnus in 9600 BC (see fig. 3), the suspected date of construction of Enclosure D based on radiometric dating.
Journey of the Soul
Pillar 43 most likely depicts the death journey of the soul of the deceased, or indeed that of the shaman. This would be the removal of a soul from its physical environment, represented by the headless figure with an erection at the base of the stone - via Scorpius, signified by the scorpion, to its final destination among the stars. This destination, arguably the entrance to the "upper world" or sky-world of Eurasian shamanic tradition, appears to have been located in the vicinity of Cygnus, represented on the pillar by the main vulture, where the soul of the individual is almost certainly shown as the ball-like object above its right-hand wing. This ball is not the sun, which surely would have been shown with greater clarity on pictorial art of this form. Professor Klaus Schmidt himself identified this ball-like object as a disembodied head of a deceased person.(19) Indeed, filled circles of this kind in the prehistoric art of Anatolia have long been recognized as symbols of the human soul.(20) This is because the seat of the soul was considered to reside in the head or skull, a belief attached to the fact that during the early Neolithic age skulls were often removed from bodies and used for oracular purposes. This is known to have occurred at Neolithic sites like Jericho (Tell es-Sultan) in Palestine. Here a number of perfectly preserved decorated skulls, dating to ca. 7000 BC, have been found that were most likely used for psychic communication with the spirit world (see fig. 4).
Figure 4. Decorated skull found at Jericho, Palestine, dating to ca. 7000 BC (Pic credit: Wiki Commons Agreement).
I demonstrate all this elsewhere,(21) and recently similar ideas regarding the carved reliefs on Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 have been voiced by Dr. Müslüm Ercan, director of Sanliurfa Museum, who is head of excavations at the site on behalf of the museum. In an article titled "Signs of world's first pictograph found in Göbeklitepe," published in Turkey's Hurriyet Daily News on July 15, 2015, he proposed that: "The scene on the obelisk unearthed in Göbeklitepe [Enclosure D's Pillar 43] could be construed as the first pictograph because it depicts an event thematically. It depicts a human head [the filled circle] in the wing of a vulture and a headless human body under the stela.(22)
"There are various figures like cranes and scorpions around this figure. This is the portrayal of a moment; it could be the first example of [a] pictograph. They are not random figures."
Ercan goes on to link the vulture imagery on Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 with the act of disposing of the dead through the practice of excarnation, along with its allied association with the transmigration of the soul: "There were no graves 12,000 years ago. The dead bodies were left outdoors and raptors [that is, vultures] ate them. In this way, people believed the soul goes to the sky." This, he said, was called "burial in the sky," i.e. sky burial, and is depicted in the carved art at Göbekli Tepe, and also at the 9,000-year-old Neolithic city of Çatalhöyük in southern-central Anatolia. Here, shown in one particular painted fresco, are two vultures at the top of a wooden excarnation tower. They feast on a human corpse, which as at Göbekli Tepe is shown as a headless individual (see fig. 5). Yet next to this scene are two more vultures on another excarnation tower that appear to be taking under their wings a ball-like head, this time with a mouth and two eyes. What we are almost certainly seeing here are the birds accepting into their care the soul of the deceased person in preparation for its journey to the next world. Other frescoes at Çatalhöyük show vultures with anthropomorphic features, suggesting they are shamans in the guise of vultures caught in the midst of ecstatic trance.
Figure 5. Frescoe from Çatalhöyük in southern-central Anatolia showing vultures devouring a corpse on the right and taking a soul into their cave on the left (pic credit: Andrew Collins).
Very likely the ball above the left wing of the vulture on Göbekli Tepe's Pillar 43 is not the sun in Sagittarius as has been recently proposed, but the soul of either a deceased person, or that of a shaman under the protective care of the vulture acting in the capacity of psychopomp, a Greek word meaning "soul carrier," or "soul accompanier." Thus the visual evidence presented by the Vulture Stone allows for a comparative and consistent interpretation of its carved relief. With this in mind, it seems more plausible to conclude, as archaeologist Müslüm Ercan has done, that the overall theme being presented by the pillar's pictorial art is one of the soul's cosmic journey, and not a pictiral record of the Younger Dryas impact event of ca. 10,800 BC. At Göbekli Tepe this death journey would have been achieved with the soul exiting this world and entering the land of the dead via the centrally placed porthole stones, or soul holes, targeting the Cygnus star Deneb as it set on the local horizon. It is thus no coincidence that Enclosure D's Pillar 43 is located immediately to the west of its porthole hole (see fig. 1), suggesting that the former is to be seen as a signboard marking the way to the land of the dead.
Although this explanation makes complete sense of the Neolithic mindset, ca. 9500-8000 BC, it is infinitely more tempting to conclude that the Vulture Stone really is a warning of impending doom from future comet impacts conveyed across time by the Göbekli builders. This is unfortunate, as despite all the evidence to the contrary, such sensationalist views will continue to influence the opinions of researchers well into the future.
Notes and References
1. Hancock, Magicians of the Gods, Coronet, 2015: 318-24.
2. Burley, Paul, "Gobekli Tepe - Temples Communicating Ancient Cosmic Geography," March 8, 2013, Graham Hancock website, http://grahamhancock.com/burleyp1/
3. Hancock, 2015: 325-7.
4. The Younger Dryas impact event features heavily in my book Gateway to Atlantis, published in 2000 and reprinted in 2016 under the title Atlantis in the Caribbean and the Comet that Changed the World. See also Collins, 2014b: chs. 12-17.
5. See, for example, Belmonte, J. A. "Finding Our Place in the Cosmos: The Role of Astronomy in Ancient Cultures." Journal of Cosmology 9 (2010): 2052-62.
6. Allen, Richard Hinckley, Star Names: Their Lore and Meaning . New York, NY: Dover Publications, 1963, s.v. "Aquila, the Eagle," 55-61.
7. Brown, Robert. Researches Into the Origin of the Primitive Constellations of the Greeks, Phoenicians and Babylonians. 2 vols. London: Williams & Norgate, 1899: I, 34-6, 234; 1900: II, 17, 148.
8. Ibid, for Aquila, 1899: I, 44-6; for Cygnus, 1899: I, 35-7 for Lyra, 1899: I, 34-6.
9. Thomas, Joseph. The Gods of Homer and Virgil; Or, Mythology for Children. London: Joseph Thomas, 1837: s.v. Harpies, 159. George Shaw identified their avian character with the Linnaeus vulture. See George Shaw, Vivarium naturæ or A Naturalist's Miscellany or Coloured Figures of Natural Objects Drawn and Described Immediately from Nature. London: G. Shaw & F. P. Nodder, 1790: s.v. Alpine vulture, npn.
10. Allen, 1899, s.v. "Aquila, the Eagle" 55-61; Allen, 1899: s.v. "Cygnus, the Swan," 192-8, and Allen, 1899: s.v. "Lyra, the Lyre or Harp," 280-8.
11. Najarian, Moses, Starry heavens and geography, Harmony House, nd., http://nerdashnaktun.org/mn_article_nh. Available only through Wayback Machine at https://archive.org/web/(choose date September 13, 2016). A link to a PDF version is offered by the current author on request.
12.Vahradyan, Vachagan, and Marine Vahradyan, "About the Astronomical Role of "Qarahunge" Monument," 2013. See also Mkrtcyan, Karine, "Il Mistero di Qarahunj," Akhtamar on line 9:182 (July 15, 2014), 2.
13. Vahradyan and Vahradyan, 2013.
14. See Paris M. Herouni, Armenians and Old Armenia: Archaeoastronomy, Linguistics, Oldest History. Yerevan, Armenia: Tigran Metz Publishing House, 2004.
17. See, for instance, Allen, 1899, for material on Cygnus, Lyra and Aquila being identified as vultures. For the three celestial birds being paranatellons of Sagittarius see s.v. "Aquila, the Eagle" 55-61.
18. Lorenzis, Alessandro de, and Vincenzo Orofino, "New Possible Astronomic Alignments at the Megalithic Site of Göbekli Tepe, Turkey," Archaeological Discovery 3, 2015, pp. 40-50.
19. Klaus Schmidt, television interview with Dr. Graham, Phillips, "Dead Cult Temples and Bog Bodies in Ireland," Ancient X-Files, National Geographic Channel, 2012.
20. Uyanik, Muvaffak, Petroglyphs of South-eastern Anatolia, Akademishe Druck-u. Verlagsanstalt, Graz, Austria, 1974, p. 12.
21. See Collins, Andrew, "Göbekli Tepe's Cosmic Blueprint Revealed" at http://www.andrewcollins.com/page/articles/Gobekli.htm.
"Signs of world's first pictograph found in Göbeklitepe," Hurriyet
Daily News, July 15, 2015, http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/signs-of-worlds-first-pictograph-found-in-Göbeklitepe-.aspx?PageID=238&NID=85438&NewsCatID=375.
more about these subjects at the Origins 2017 event in London on November 4th,
Click for more information and immediate registration
CLICK TO RETURN TO NEWS PAGE